Ask Monty, July '08

Read legal disclaimer here.

07/02/08: I have a 5 year old Thoroughbred gelding who has a big problem with horse trailers. He used to be decent, he would load for food and paw a little, but never anything serious. A few months ago, he threw a huge tantrum in the trailer and somehow managed to flip himself over backwards in my two horse trailer. I don't know what triggered this fit. He had been in this same trailer many times and shipped alone more often than not.

Immediately following his accident, he loaded with no problem into a much larger trailer, a three horse with a box stall sized area in the back used to tack up the horses and he traveled fine. I assume this is because he was stunned from the accident and I was riding in the trailer with him. The next time I put him in a trailer he was very reluctant to load, but eventually he climbed on for his grain.

He was perfectly fine until I got out of the trailer and was no longer in his sight. Once he couldn't see me, he had another fit. He was in a stock trailer, so we could see him thrashing around and trying to break the lead he was tied with. We decided to untie him, and he decided to run circles in the trailer for the entire two and a half hour drive from Maryland back to New Jersey.

After the accident, I'm very nervous about putting him back on the trailer again, but he needs to be able to trailer safely. I've talked to several local trainers, and none of them want to work with him. Do you have any advice for teaching him to behave in the trailer? Can you recommend any trainers that would be willing to help me with him?

Thanks,
Rachael

07/09/08: My Quarter Horse throws his head up when I go to take the bit out of his mouth, yet always puts his head down like he should when I go to put it on and when I start to take off the bridle. When I start to take the bit out of his mouth, his head goes up. What should I do?

Sincerely, Katie   

07/16/08: I have recently attended your demonstration at Quob stables in Southampton, after a seven hour journey from Sunderland in the North East and it was the most worthwhile journey of my life! Both of our horses have been treated with nothing but kindness for all of their lives. However my horse, an eleven year old grey Arab gelding, has a tendency to nap if in the front on the ride. He is fine if he has a horse in front or beside him, and will go in front for a time, but will then stop and try to turn around.

I want to solve this and know that I should make this behavior less comfortable for him, and have tried using rein back, but as this is not something that comes naturally to him it is proving difficult. I am in the process of teaching him this in the school, but was wondering if there were any alternatives that you could suggest, as turning round in circles, as I have often read you suggest, is difficult as it is mostly on a single track that this behaviour is exhibited! Any ideas?
 
Kirsty McLachlan and Sheikh Shalamzar (Shaky) Sunderland

07/23/08: Wild Mustangs Feeding Times
When you were living with the wild Mustangs did you notice a particular pattern or time that the horses would eat. Was it the same time each day and how often? Thank you.
Cynthia

7/30/08: I was wondering if you could suggest a training technique for my horse. He is deathly frightened of flies, which in itself is not so bad, but here in Australia they are in plague proportions throughout summer. I have tried, too many to mention, chemicals, one of which does help.  It is used for Dairy cattle for fly strike on their ears. I just don't feel it is safe to continually use it as it is extremely toxic for humans and makes me wonder what it is doing to him over the long term.
 
I tried a lady who "talks" to the horses and she explained that he had been stung by several bees and now is extremely frightened of anything that lands on his exposed body.  I have tried leaving him without rugs on during the day, to which he will not come out of his loose box except at night.  I have tried to feed him outside, to which he eats and then gallops the 5 meters or so back into his shed and quivers wedged into the corner because something lands on him.  Although nothing will get him out during the day: no hay, buckets of molasses water (his favorite) or his dinner or anything I can think of to place within one step outside. I had a friend who laughed out of disbelief until he almost killed her when she got between him and his box.  Now, suffice to say, she is no longer laughing and is just as worried as me.

 
I just feel as though there must be something I can do to help to explain to him that not everything bites. I know he looks to me for help (he is a rather large Mummy's' boy or softy) as I can see a scream for help in his eyes and it is killing me to see him like that and not be able to do anything to help him. Having said all this, the minute I throw a cotton rug over his body, he is coming out of the shed to graze, even before I have time to do the straps up. Just having something over him is enough.  When he does eventually come out, he is starving but exhausted too, which makes me aware of the fact that he does not come out at all during the day. I have now had to place a water bucket near him as I am worried that he does not drink either, purely out of fear of coming out of the shed.
It is leaving me at my wits end trying to help him. It is also now becoming dangerous as I am frightened of the fact he is now throwing himself (hips and shoulders) straight at the walls. It is as though he tries to commit suicide when something lands on him. He glazes over in his eyes and just looses all focus on reality and is becoming quite dangerous to be around during the day.
 
I know I am on the other side of the world but I just hoped it was something that you may find quite "normal" and could possibly give me some hope of a normal life during the 3-4 months of fly invasions over the summer. Everyone I have spoken to, including several vets (and I will say most are sick of me by now) have never in their lives seen anything like it and have no ideas for me to try that I haven't already tried earlier.  This has been going on for the past 3 summers and I was hoping it wouldn't rear its head during this one but he has already started to show the signs again and we haven't even come into summer yet even though the few days of sunshine has brought out a few flies.

Your advice on this matter would be HEAVEN SENT for me and my boy.  He is just so gentle and loving and always tries his hardest to please everyone he comes in contact with. He is a Clydesdale cross Quarter Horse, so he is a heavy boy to be crashing into the walls of wash bays and stables all because of a tiny little fly.

I realise this letter may take a while to get through due to your huge popularity but I live and hope.
Sincerely yours
Marnie Gilchrist

Monty's Answers to July 2008 Questions

Question
I have a 5 year old Thoroughbred gelding who has a big problem with horse trailers. He used to be decent, he would load for food and paw a little, but never anything serious. A few months ago, he threw a huge tantrum in the trailer and somehow managed to flip himself over backwards in my two horse trailer. I don't know what triggered this fit. He had been in this same trailer many times and shipped alone more often than not.

Immediately following his accident, he loaded with no problem into a much larger trailer, a three horse with a box stall sized area in the back used to tack up the horses and he traveled fine. I assume this is because he was stunned from the accident and I was riding in the trailer with him. The next time I put him in a trailer he was very reluctant to load, but eventually he climbed on for his grain.

He was perfectly fine until I got out of the trailer and was no longer in his sight. Once he couldn't see me, he had another fit. He was in a stock trailer, so we could see him thrashing around and trying to break the lead he was tied with. We decided to untie him, and he decided to run circles in the trailer for the entire two and a half hour drive from Maryland back to New Jersey.

After the accident, I'm very nervous about putting him back on the trailer again, but he needs to be able to trailer safely. I've talked to several local trainers, and none of them want to work with him. Do you have any advice for teaching him to behave in the trailer? Can you recommend any trainers that would be willing to help me with him?

Thanks,

Rachael

 

Monty's Answer

The problem that you outline is far more common than most people realize. You have a horse and a horse is a flight animal and flight animals are virtually all herd animals. Horses belong to a species more reliant on the herd than almost any other we know. Being isolated away from the herd can potentially drive a horse absolutely mad.

You probably have a nice horse and while he possesses strong herd instincts it sounds as though he tried very hard for a significant period of time to live with your decision to transport him in an isolated state. At some point however, he just couldn’t take it anymore and when he began to throw his fit he realized what a horrible place small trailers really are.

You horse is claustrophobic but don’t you panic. All horses are claustrophobic. It’s just that many of them will try hard to live with their claustrophobia and not cause any problems. You horse is on that list. Now he realizes that he simply hates trailers but I think you can do something to help him through this problem.

When you related the part of the story about how he tolerated the trailer quite well when you were in it, my mind went to a thought pattern that was like “This is a set up question” because it is too cool that your horse was so textbook expressive.

It tells me a lot of things about you and how you deal with your horse in the general relationship that you have with him. A: He trusts you. B: He looks up to you. C: He is willing to regard you as a friend and even a herd mate. That is a very impressive set of circumstances to say the least.

Now what do we do about all of this? Well, let’s look at the facts. He needs space, he needs a friend and he needs the necessary circumstances so that he regards his environment as a safe place. If you provide him with an appropriate friend he probably does not need your presence.

It is my opinion that he will eventually haul in a “slant-haul” trailer rather than a conventional one and the friend does not have to be another horse. I have seen donkeys work well in these circumstances. Ponies and other horses usually do fine providing that a significant bonding time is achieved. I have seen goats and sheep do the job; even dogs and would you believe that I knew a man that used a parrot?

The parrot lived in their stable with the horse and they were the best of friends. The parrot talked to him all the time and although there were no answers, one would swear that the horse knew what he was saying. This particular horse flew all over the world in airplanes and traveled in trailers and vans but without the parrot he was a basket case.

Read the chapter on transporting horses in From My Hands to Yours, use good judgment in implementing these concepts and have fun achieving safe and stress-free travel for both you and your horse. You can do it!


-Monty 

Question
My Quarter Horse throws his head up when I go to take the bit out of his mouth, yet always puts his head down like he should when I go to put it on and when I start to take off the bridle. When I start to take the bit out of his mouth, his head goes up. What should I do?
Sincerely, Katie
  

Monty's Answer
My suggestion to you is that you place your horse in a fairly small area where twisting and turning is restricted. I recommend that you get a bit taller by standing on a small stool or something safe but elevated. Once you have achieved these two elements then I suggest that you rub your horses head all over scratching and rubbing the ears until he is comfortable with all your movements while he is in that position.

With the above recommendations well in place then I suggest that you use a small stick or piece of doweling about a foot long. Put honey on one end of the stick and then begin to slide it in and out of the horse’s mouth. You could begin at the corners of the mouth but when the horse is accepting the stick and licking the honey start to extract the stick through the teeth.

These same procedures are outlined in From My Hands to Yours but mainly to accept the bit and not for extraction. The training is very similar though and should be done with wood so there is not the metallic clanking when it touches the teeth. Once your horse will open his teeth and allow the stick to pass through easily then you can put honey on a snaffle bit (only the metal portion) and repeat the process until he is comfortable.

With each of those recommendations in place, one can add a bridle (headstall) and eventually reins until your horse is a perfect gentleman about releasing the bit. This remedial problem probably began with one bad experience which created a phobia. It is your obligation to let your horse know that nothing is going to hurt him during the act of opening his mouth and releasing the bit.

You can also use the Dually halter effectively as a bitless bridle. That is, you can ride a horse with the reins connected to each of the training rings. This bitless bridle is very effective when there is a practical reason not to ride the horse with a bit.

-Monty

Question
I have recently attended your demonstration at Quob stables in Southampton, after a seven hour journey from Sunderland in the North East and it was the most worthwhile journey of my life! Both of our horses have been treated with nothing but kindness for all of their lives. However my horse, an eleven year old grey Arab gelding, has a tendency to nap if in the front on the ride. He is fine if he has a horse in front or beside him, and will go in front for a time, but will then stop and try to turn around.

I want to solve this and know that I should make this behavior less comfortable for him, and have tried using rein back, but as this is not something that comes naturally to him it is proving difficult. I am in the process of teaching him this in the school, but was wondering if there were any alternatives that you could suggest, as turning round in circles, as I have often read you suggest, is difficult as it is mostly on a single track that this behaviour is exhibited! Any ideas?
 
Kirsty McLachlan and Sheikh Shalamzar (Shaky) Sunderland

Monty's Answer
Reining back is not a natural thing for any horse but please understand that it is my position that reining back is critically essential to achieving a trained riding horse. The owners of “nappers” will, in a high percentage of cases, suggest that their horse just does not like reining back. Therein lays the problem. It is essential that riders of these individuals work hard on techniques which will improve the horses reverse or live with the problems this phenomenon creates.

I remember the insertion of a drawing in my textbook From My Hands To Yours that depicts a narrow lane or raceway created by placing panels or gates next to a wall. I recall explaining how riding the horse into that area and then backing out will dramatically improve the process of training a horse to back up.

Whether or not you improve the trail riding behavior of your horse, achieving a better reverse will cause this individual to do many things better for you. His stop will improve and even turning left and right will become a better proposition once reining back is achieved to the extent that your horse does it willingly and with generosity.

- Monty

Question
When you were living with the wild Mustangs did you notice a particular pattern or time that the horses would eat. Was it the same time each day and how often? Thank you.
Cynthia

Monty's Answer
There are definite patterns where eating is concerned whether it is herds of Mustangs or domestic horses. Like so many other animals there is a strong tendency to do most of the eating in the extremes of the day. Just breaking daylight and sunset times will produce more feverish grazing than any other time of the day.

Whether there is a moon or not horses will do a fair bit of grazing at night and probably the center of the day is reserved for shade and rest more than any other time. The least amount of grazing generally occurs mid-day.


Question
I was wondering if you could suggest a training technique for my horse. He is deathly frightened of flies, which in itself is not so bad, but here in Australia they are in plague proportions throughout summer. I have tried, too many to mention, chemicals, one of which does help.  It is used for Dairy cattle for fly strike on their ears. I just don't feel it is safe to continually use it as it is extremely toxic for humans and makes me wonder what it is doing to him over the long term.
 
I tried a lady who "talks" to the horses and she explained that he had been stung by several bees and now is extremely frightened of anything that lands on his exposed body.  I have tried leaving him without rugs on during the day, to which he will not come out of his loose box except at night.  I have tried to feed him outside, to which he eats and then gallops the 5 meters or so back into his shed and quivers wedged into the corner because something lands on him.  Although nothing will get him out during the day: no hay, buckets of molasses water (his favorite) or his dinner or anything I can think of to place within one step outside. I had a friend who laughed out of disbelief until he almost killed her when she got between him and his box.  Now, suffice to say, she is no longer laughing and is just as worried as me.
 
I just feel as though there must be something I can do to help to explain to him that not everything bites. I know he looks to me for help (he is a rather large Mummy's' boy or softy) as I can see a scream for help in his eyes and it is killing me to see him like that and not be able to do anything to help him. Having said all this, the minute I throw a cotton rug over his body, he is coming out of the shed to graze, even before I have time to do the straps up. Just having something over him is enough.  When he does eventually come out, he is starving but exhausted too, which makes me aware of the fact that he does not come out at all during the day. I have now had to place a water bucket near him as I am worried that he does not drink either, purely out of fear of coming out of the shed.
It is leaving me at my wits end trying to help him. It is also now becoming dangerous as I am frightened of the fact he is now throwing himself (hips and shoulders) straight at the walls. It is as though he tries to commit suicide when something lands on him. He glazes over in his eyes and just looses all focus on reality and is becoming quite dangerous to be around during the day.
 
I know I am on the other side of the world but I just hoped it was something that you may find quite "normal" and could possibly give me some hope of a normal life during the 3-4 months of fly invasions over the summer. Everyone I have spoken to, including several vets (and I will say most are sick of me by now) have never in their lives seen anything like it and have no ideas for me to try that I haven't already tried earlier.  This has been going on for the past 3 summers and I was hoping it wouldn't rear its head during this one but he has already started to show the signs again and we haven't even come into summer yet even though the few days of sunshine has brought out a few flies.

Your advice on this matter would be HEAVEN SENT for me and my boy.  He is just so gentle and loving and always tries his hardest to please everyone he comes in contact with. He is a Clydesdale cross Quarter Horse, so he is a heavy boy to be crashing into the walls of wash bays and stables all because of a tiny little fly.

I realise this letter may take a while to get through due to your huge popularity but I live and hope.
Sincerely yours
Marnie Gilchrist

 
Monty's Answer:
You have sent me what quite possibly might be the most unique question I have come across. In your letter you mention that I might find this condition quite normal. Let me assure you that I do not find it normal and that I can't recall ever having this question asked of me nor do I remember dealing with the phenomenon as you have outlined it.

In my career I have dealt with cattle that lost weight running from heel flies and I have seen horses that would express episodes of anger with biting flies. I even advised a horse breeding operation once about clouds of mosquitoes that literally caused their broodmares to go bald during the summer. But I have never dealt with the traumatic aspects of the problem that you described.

We used some repellent on the mares but helped them mostly by covering them up. I don't know if the extreme heat would preclude the use of lightweight sheets on this horse but that is where my mind is going. I am wondering if it is more psychosomatic than it is real and I suppose it could come down to a simple net that could give him the feeling of safety while letting the air pass through allowing him to stay cooler. As mentioned in your question, a cotton rug makes all the difference. There are some great fly sheets available that can cover all the body including the belly and neck and even face. You can get the ones for sweet-itch as well that completely cover the horse. If he is happy to come out wearing a rug like that then he would come and go out of his stall and be happier and keep drinking and not stressing.

I think trying to desensitize him to such an adverse fear would take quite a while and if he was in a bee or wasp attack then that can be a pretty traumatic thing to overcome and the memories of things landing on him can be quite ingrained. My suggestion for the summer fly months would be a fly sheet and giving him the option of his stall and making sure he always has water and appropriate feed available to him when he is in there, not allowing him access to water or feed will add to the trauma and stress of trying to hide from the flies. I suggest a long strong search for the best covers you can find. Experiment with the fine net types with the non-toxic repellents and try to get him older and wiser without being munched on. Keep him covered up as much as possible.
 
- Monty 

Continue to June 2008 Ask Monty >

Return to main Ask Monty page >


monty roberts email signup
Get ASK MONTY Tips Free
Your Email:
For Email Marketing you can trust
©2008 Monty and Pat Roberts. All Rights Reserved.